Research

HIFT training: log enjoyment apart from strength

By

In short

In a small eight-week trial, HIFT had higher adjusted upper-body strength and enjoyment than HIIT. Body composition did not significantly differ between the workouts. Track the exercise experience, attendance and lifting results separately.

Enjoying HIFT more is a useful observation without turning it into a fat-loss claim. A randomized trial published on October 27, 2026 found differences in upper-body strength and the exercise experience, but no significant body-composition differences between HIFT and HIIT. The distinction matters when choosing a class: a result about how training feels answers a different question from a result about how much body fat changes.

What did the eight-week comparison involve?

Twenty-four people were randomized; 22 completed the study and entered the final analysis.
GroupAnalyzedCondition
HIFT: high-intensity functional training7Three supervised sessions weekly for eight weeks
HIIT: high-intensity interval training7Three supervised sessions weekly for eight weeks
Control8Comparison for the exercise groups

Participants were insufficiently active young adults with obesity. Both exercise groups had higher baseline-adjusted relative peak oxygen consumption and first ventilatory threshold than control, with no significant difference between exercise groups. Baseline-adjusted absolute upper-body strength favored HIFT over HIIT; lower-body strength did not differ. Enjoyment and affective valence, adjusted for the first session, also favored HIFT, while perceived exertion and heart rate did not differ. Whole-body fat mass, body-fat percentage and fat-free mass showed no significant between-group differences. These are distinct outcomes, rather than one overall score declaring a winning workout.

How should enjoyment enter a lifting log?

  1. After class, note whether you enjoyed the session and would choose it again. Treat that as your exercise experience, not as a completed attendance record or proof of a future habit.
  2. Count actual sessions separately. Three supervised sessions per week was the study prescription; it does not establish how reliably someone will attend unsupervised training afterward.
  3. Record exercise loads and repetitions in fairlift. Do not convert this study's upper-body strength finding into an expected bench-press 1RM increase or a higher Muscle Index for yourself.

The final analysis covered 22 young adults with obesity over eight weeks. It cannot establish outcomes for experienced lifters, long-term fat loss or long-term adherence. A nonsignificant body-composition comparison also does not prove that the two methods have identical effects.

Frequently asked questions

Is HIFT better than HIIT for losing body fat?

This trial found no significant body-composition difference between the two exercise groups. Whole-body fat mass, body-fat percentage and fat-free mass also showed no significant between-group differences, so the findings do not establish a HIFT fat-loss advantage.

Does greater enjoyment mean someone will keep exercising?

Enjoyment ratings and long-term adherence are different outcomes. A difference during an eight-week trial cannot establish attendance or dropout months afterward.

Will HIFT improve the big three lifts more?

Adjusted absolute upper-body strength favored HIFT over HIIT, but that does not establish superiority for the squat, bench press and deadlift total. Measure your own lifts rather than translating the group result into a predicted personal record.

Source: PubMed — HIFT versus HIIT randomized trial (published )

Calculate your strength score →

Enter your Big 3 lifts and bodyweight for a relative strength score corrected for age and height. Free, no account needed.

Keep reading